I think that this quote make it obvious that a Socratic examination ultimately is an examination of consistency in values. When we are “being reminded of flaws in past and presented behavior”, the Socratic examination makes us realize our flaws ourselves and the flaws we see are flaws that has consequences for our behavior. We are not being lectured and it is not an examination of pure logical consistency.
"I don’t think you appreciate what happens when you come into close proximity with Socrates and strike up a conversation with him. Whatever the original topic of your conversation, eventually he’s bound to head you off and to trap you into trying to explain your own way of life and how you’ve lived up to now. And once you’re caught in the trap, Socrates won’t let you go until he’s subjected every detail to a thorough, rigorous test. I’m familiar with his ways and I know that such treatment at his hands is inevitable. Besides, I’m sure to face it myself, because I enjoy his company, Lysimachus, and I don’t think there’s any harm in being reminded of flaws in our past or present behaviour. On the contrary, in the future you’re bound to be more thoughtful if you don’t avoid this treatment but submit to it, bearing in mind what Solon said, and expect to go on learning as long as you live, rather than imagining that old age arrives with wisdom in its train. Anyway, in my view being examined by Socrates isn’t at all odd or unpleasant."
- The character Nicias in Plato's dialogue Laches, 187e ff.
Socratic consistency
Socratic consistency
Socratic consistency
I think that this quote make it obvious that a Socratic examination ultimately is an examination of consistency in values. When we are “being reminded of flaws in past and presented behavior”, the Socratic examination makes us realize our flaws ourselves and the flaws we see are flaws that has consequences for our behavior. We are not being lectured and it is not an examination of pure logical consistency.
"I don’t think you appreciate what happens when you come into close proximity with Socrates and strike up a conversation with him. Whatever the original topic of your conversation, eventually he’s bound to head you off and to trap you into trying to explain your own way of life and how you’ve lived up to now. And once you’re caught in the trap, Socrates won’t let you go until he’s subjected every detail to a thorough, rigorous test. I’m familiar with his ways and I know that such treatment at his hands is inevitable. Besides, I’m sure to face it myself, because I enjoy his company, Lysimachus, and I don’t think there’s any harm in being reminded of flaws in our past or present behaviour. On the contrary, in the future you’re bound to be more thoughtful if you don’t avoid this treatment but submit to it, bearing in mind what Solon said, and expect to go on learning as long as you live, rather than imagining that old age arrives with wisdom in its train. Anyway, in my view being examined by Socrates isn’t at all odd or unpleasant."
- The character Nicias in Plato's dialogue Laches, 187e ff.